© Copyright Acquisition International 2025 - All Rights Reserved.

Article Image - Cross-Border M&A Is Hot, but There’s a Trap for Tax Planners
Posted 10th September 2015

Cross-Border M&A Is Hot, but There’s a Trap for Tax Planners

Cross-border mergers and acquisitions are at their hottest pace since before the financial crisis. In fact, M&A volume was $1.10 trillion in 2014, up from $775.3 billion in 2013 and the highest since 2008.

Mouse Scroll AnimationScroll to keep reading

Let us help promote your business to a wider following.

Cross-Border M&A Is Hot, but There’s a Trap for Tax Planners

Cross-Border M&A Is Hot, but There’s a Trap for Tax Planners

Deal-Building

Cross-border mergers and acquisitions are at their hottest pace since before the financial crisis. In fact, M&A volume was $1.10 trillion in 2014, up from $775.3 billion in 2013 and the highest since 2008. 

Intangible assets like intellectual property and goodwill play an increasingly large role in these transactions. However, there’s a trap for corporate tax and financial planners, warns New York accounting firm Marks Paneth: Using the wrong method to value intangibles can raise red flags to tax authorities and lead to audits, penalties or regulatory actions, or to lengthy litigation.

One of the valuation methods — financial reporting — results in significantly lower valuations for intangibles than the other — transfer pricing. The financial reporting approach is standard in most transactions. But when the transaction is cross-border, different rules come into play that may require the transfer pricing method, which leads to a higher valuation and a bigger tax bill.

“Tax planners need to understand the differences between the two methods and know which to apply — the wrong choice can result in costly penalties and sanctions, or protracted litigation,” says Angela Sadang, Director in the Financial Advisory Services group at Marks Paneth.

“Tax authorities frown on low valuations,” Ms. Sadang says, “especially when that makes it easier to transfer an asset to a more favorable tax jurisdiction. The IRS and other tax authorities have warned that financial reporting valuations should only be used as a ‘starting point’ for transfer pricing and may not stand up to scrutiny. Courts don’t always agree — the IRS has lost two major transfer-pricing cases. But defending those cases can be expensive and isn’t guaranteed to work.”

Ms. Sadang highlights the best method for valuing intangibles in cross-border M&A and the risks of getting it wrong. Among them:

•             Why there’s confusion about valuing intangible assets: “There are two different valuation methods that use very different basic assumptions,” Ms. Sadang says. “The method used for financial reporting differs in fundamental ways from the method used in transfer pricing. Transfer pricing is usually the basis for taxation in cross-border transactions, since tax is often determined when an asset is moved from one jurisdiction to another. Also, transfer pricing typically produces a higher valuation than financial reporting, so there is more tax to be collected when transfer pricing is used.”

•             How the two different methods produce such different results: “There are several major differences between the two methods. Among the most significant is that in transfer pricing, goodwill is considered part of the value of an intangible asset, and the valuation is determined from the perspective of an actual buyer. In financial reporting, goodwill is not a part of the asset, and the valuation is determined from the perspective of a market participant. Market factors generally lead to a lower price. In addition, transfer pricing is done on a pre-tax basis and estimates a longer useful life. Financial reporting is done on an after-tax basis and assumes a shorter useful life. For those reasons and others, the transfer pricing method produces a much higher valuation than the financial reporting method.”

•             The consequences of choosing the wrong method: “Tax authorities including the IRS and the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) are tightening controls. The IRS has issued guidance that financial reporting valuations, specifically purchase price allocations, should only be used as a ‘starting point’ for transfer pricing purposes and may not be probative. The OECD is moving similarly to make sure that member countries do not assign a low value to intangible assets in order to transfer them into a more favorable tax jurisdiction. So far, the IRS has been unsuccessful in court — the courts ruled in favor of taxpayers in two major cases, Veritas and Xilinx. But indications are that authorities will continue to press for the transfer pricing method. Companies may face audits or litigation if they apply the financial reporting method.”

Categories: Finance, M&A


You Might Also Like
Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Cargill Beefs up Capabilities, Commitment to Protein, with South Carolina Plant Purchase
M&A
04/03/2016Cargill Beefs up Capabilities, Commitment to Protein, with South Carolina Plant Purchase

People in the eastern United States enjoy good beef burgers and beginning this spring Cargill will be able to better meet those needs through the acquisition of the FPL Food, LLC ground beef processing plant in Columbia, S.C. Purchase of the 100,000-square-foo

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
5 In-Demand Degrees That Can Boost Your Career
News
12/04/20245 In-Demand Degrees That Can Boost Your Career

Image source In an era marked by rapid technological advancements and shifting economic landscapes, career advancement often hinges on one’s ability to adapt and grow in alignment with emerging trends. Identifying and pursuing in-demand degrees can serve

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
A Guide on Integrating RD Tax Credit Software and Its Benefits
News
10/07/2023A Guide on Integrating RD Tax Credit Software and Its Benefits

RD Tax Credit Software is a specialized software tool designed to help businesses and organizations claim the Research & Development (R&D) Tax Credit. This type of software can be used to accurately calculate and track eligible expenses, analyze the re

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Beech Tree Private Equity Announce Their First Mid-Market Fund, “BTPE FUND 1”
Finance
16/04/2015Beech Tree Private Equity Announce Their First Mid-Market Fund, “BTPE FUND 1”

Beech Tree Private Equity (“BTPE”) today announces the launch of its first fund, backed by leading institutional investors.

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Maybelline New York Introduces its Conscious Together Programme
Corporate Social Responsibility
28/01/2022Maybelline New York Introduces its Conscious Together Programme

The Conscious Together programme aims to create a more responsible business model for the brand by transforming its processes, innovations, and mindset to reduce its impact on the planet, with four ambitions set to be achieved by 2030.

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
How Are Carpet Cleaning Companies Embracing The Eco-Friendly Approach
News
04/03/2024How Are Carpet Cleaning Companies Embracing The Eco-Friendly Approach

The current trend in carpet cleaning methods Reputable carpet cleaning Hammersmith companies are now transitioning towards eco-friendly cleaning solutions, representing a shift of direction towards sustainable living. By embracing the efforts to cut down on to

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Reputation for Dedication
Legal
05/02/2021Reputation for Dedication

When Mr. Guy Matthews established his law firm in 1972, he did so with the vision of serving two distinct but related purposes: to protect intellectual property rights and enforce those rights through litigation. Matthews, Lawson, McCutcheon & Joseph, PLLC

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Atlas Genetics Completes $20m Series C Fundraising
Finance
Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
A Level Playing Field
Legal
26/06/2017A Level Playing Field

HHC Services, Inc. provides safety engineering consulting and expert witness services. Included in the Most Highly Regarded Expert Witnesses 2017 awards, we took the opportunity to interview the firm’s Dr. Janine McCartney to learn more about her own special



Our Trusted Brands

Acquisition International is a flagship brand of AI Global Media. AI Global Media is a B2B enterprise and are committed to creating engaging content allowing businesses to market their services to a larger global audience. We have 14 unique brands, each of which serves a specific industry or region. Each brand covers the latest news in its sector and publishes a digital magazine and newsletter which is read by a global audience.

Arrow