© Copyright Acquisition International 2025 - All Rights Reserved.

Article Image - Commercial Disputes: The Pros and Cons of Arbitration
Posted 17th July 2024

Commercial Disputes: The Pros and Cons of Arbitration

Litigation – that is, formally dealing with a dispute through the parties’ domestic courts – has long been the go-to solution when commercial disputes arise, but this form of dispute resolution has been regarded as lengthy, costly, and does little to preserve any commercial goodwill between the parties involved.

Mouse Scroll AnimationScroll to keep reading

Let us help promote your business to a wider following.

Commercial Disputes: The Pros and Cons of Arbitration
Court

By Yulia Barnes, Founder and Managing Partner of Barnes Law.

Litigation – that is, formally dealing with a dispute through the parties’ domestic courts – has long been the go-to solution when commercial disputes arise, but this form of dispute resolution has been regarded as lengthy, costly, and does little to preserve any commercial goodwill between the parties involved.

Conversely, Arbitration has become an internationally welcome form of commercial dispute resolution.

So, what does arbitration entail, and is it the right choice for you should you find yourself at the centre of an ongoing commercial dispute?

What is arbitration?

There are times where formal litigation is unavoidable. However, both commercially and within the judiciary, there is a growing interest in, and encouragement of, alternative dispute resolution [ADR] – that is, procedures for resolving disputes outside of court.

Arbitration is one such form of ADR.   The powers of an arbitral center or court stems from the New York Convention 1958, under which contracting states agree that their domestic courts shall recognise and enforce foreign arbitral awards. Examples of the most prominent arbitration centers and courts include the London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA), the Swiss Arbitration Centre, the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre (HKIC), and the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC).

A contractual clause may provide that a particular arbitration center will have jurisdiction to consider a potential dispute. However, a dispute may be referred to arbitration by way of separate arbitration agreement.  

The parties involved in the dispute will then appoint an arbitrator – an impartial third party with expertise in the area in dispute. This might be a single person, a sole-arbitrator, or an arbitral tribunal. An arbitration clause or agreement may also determine how the tribunal will be formed. As well as possessing specialist insight into the relevant areas involved in the dispute, the tribunal can include the most well-respected and experienced lawyers within that jurisdiction and can often include lawyers qualified in both civil and common law, which is particularly useful in cross-border disputes.  

 The arbitration will be governed by the procedural rules published by the various arbitration centres, which are drafted to provide the parties with flexibility and choice as to procedure. Any hearings can take place in a venue within the ‘place’ (location) of the arbitration, whilst the agreed ‘seat’ of the arbitration (the applicable law) will determine how the arbitration is supervised and conducted. Despite not taking place in court, it’s important to note that the decision made by an arbitration tribunal is legally binding, meaning parties are obligated to follow it. As above, parties may also turn to the domestic courts to seek enforcement of an arbitral award.

Benefits of arbitration

Perhaps the greatest asset of arbitration as a method for solving commercial disputes is the parties’ (and the tribunal’s) ability to expedite the resolution of the claim, compared with the domestic courts. Court processes are often slow, so parties wishing for a speedy resolution to their dispute may opt for arbitration on this advantage alone. In most cases, arbitrators can deal with a dispute within the proposed timescale of the parties involved.

Related to this is increased flexibility of the arbitration process, where the process can be better adapted to the availability of the parties, compared with a court process which is far more fixed and rigid.

Arbitration can also be a more cost-effective option, as the quicker resolution time reduces the time spent attending to the dispute that can be focused on the parties’ respective commercial interests.

Commercial disputes can often be highly technical, and as such, the ability to appoint an arbitrator who is an expert in the subject matter in question is yet another huge advantage over litigation, as is the ability for parties to choose their arbitrators. In court proceedings, no such choice over the presiding judge exists.

Finally, court proceedings are open to the public. For sensitive commercial disputes where parties wish for their interests to remain private, the arbitration process offers this confidentiality.

Drawbacks of arbitration

Arbitration offers some unique benefits as a method of dispute resolution when compared with litigation, but there are also some potential disadvantages associated with going down the arbitration route.

Though often a cost-effective option when compared to litigation, arbitration can still pose a significant cost, particularly in cases where the dispute is complex. Likewise, in these complicated instances, litigation may still be a speedier resolution, such as instances where finding mutually acceptable hearing dates is a challenge.

Like litigation, arbitration is still fundamentally an adversarial process, and as such, parties may be unhappy with the decision imposed upon them. Due to this adversarial process, those in the middle of a commercial dispute wishing to preserve as much goodwill between parties as possible, may still prefer to investigate other methods of ADR, such as mediation.

The decision of the arbitrator is legally binding, but unlike in court proceedings, this decision can be incredibly difficult to appeal, offering little in the way of recourse for parties that find themselves at a disadvantage at the end of the arbitration process. Similarly, though this decision is legally binding, it is not legally enforceable, and in some instances, enforcing the decision of the arbitrator may still require a judicial remedy.

Is arbitration right for your business?

Deciding whether litigation, arbitration or a different form of dispute resolution is the best option for you requires weighing up these various pros and cons as related to your specific commercial dispute.

One of the key considerations here should be the exact nature and complexity of the dispute in question, as well as its technical nature. Naturally, your budget and time constraints will also play a role in determining the best method to pursue, but more broadly, it’s also important to consider how significant the impact this dispute might have on your business is. Privacy concerns may also play a central role here, so it’s crucial to consider whether the confidentiality of the arbitration process is better suited to your needs than court proceedings that are a matter of public record.

Finally, you may want to consider how important maintaining a cordial and positive relationship with the other party involved in the dispute is. In situations where an opposing party is hostile, uncooperative or obstructive to the arbitration process, litigation may be your only recourse.

Final thoughts

Choosing the right method for solving business disputes as they arise is vital to ensuring your commercial interests are protected. Dispute resolution is a complex area to navigate, so it is important not only to understand the advantages and disadvantages of alternatives to litigation such as arbitration, but to also have access to the right legal advice to ensure your best interests are served throughout the dispute resolution process.

Categories: Legal, News


You Might Also Like
Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Italian Firm Finds International Success
Legal
22/03/2020Italian Firm Finds International Success

The intricacies of law can lead some companies to become specialists in their specific geographic areas, but it can also inspire businesses to look further afield for ways in which to operate and innovate. One of the firms that sees innovation as essential is

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Helsingborg-Helsingør route
Finance
19/03/2015Helsingborg-Helsingør route

First State Investments has reached financial close for its acquisition of the Helsingborg - Helsingør ferry route, raising about €230 million ($261 million) equivalent of debt from three commercial banks and a debt fund. A joint-venture between ferry opera

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
St Ives Acquire Solstice Mobile
M&A
25/03/2015St Ives Acquire Solstice Mobile

St Ives Group acquires US-based Solstice Mobile to further strengthen digital capabilities and international footprint.

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Planning for Future Financial Security
Finance
25/10/2019Planning for Future Financial Security

An international consulting firm with offices in London, Miami and New York, Intercorp Group serves high-networth entrepreneurs and their families, finding solutions to often very personal issues. Founded by Leonardo Braune, discover why this firm’s success

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Customers Aren’t Numbers, But They Really Count
M&A
05/08/2020Customers Aren’t Numbers, But They Really Count

When acquisitions go wrong, it’s because of a failure to look after the people involved, and there are none more important than customers, writes Carlene Jackson of Cloud9 Insight.

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
A Notary for Your Diary – The Seal of Approval That Every Business Needs
Legal
22/01/2015A Notary for Your Diary – The Seal of Approval That Every Business Needs

With only 800 in the country, finding and accessing a Notary Public for England and Wales can take up valuable time and resources.

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Most Innovative Tax Service Provider – UK
Finance
20/05/2016Most Innovative Tax Service Provider – UK

We at The Oxford Silk Partnership have been providing bespoke business services for over thirty years.

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Offsite Team Building: Does Your Company Need It?
News
30/01/2023Offsite Team Building: Does Your Company Need It?

Team building is, in the broad sense of the term, the process of forming and improving a team. Ideally, this is a complex of diverse activities aimed at forming an effective team, competent distribution of roles, and productive interaction of team members.

Read Full PostRead - Eye Icon
Home Away From Home
Innovation
02/03/2021Home Away From Home

Ghana is rapidly growing into a major country on the international stage. with the region's expansion unquestionable, the importance of its capital city continues to increase. Accra has much to commend it, including the delightful @Home Boutique Hostel & S



Our Trusted Brands

Acquisition International is a flagship brand of AI Global Media. AI Global Media is a B2B enterprise and are committed to creating engaging content allowing businesses to market their services to a larger global audience. We have 14 unique brands, each of which serves a specific industry or region. Each brand covers the latest news in its sector and publishes a digital magazine and newsletter which is read by a global audience.

Arrow